bharatbhasha.com
Free Articles  >>  Legal >>  Page 231  >> 

Debtor Examinations And Third Parties





"My debtor has a second house, he brags about it, and I know his buddy has been to the second home often. The second house is not findable by me as the debtor's name. How can I drag the friend of the debtor into court to disclose what he knows about the debtor's house?"

Often, to attempt to get a judgment satisfied, one need to bring in the debtor for a debtor's examination. Other times, you may need to bring in the spouse, business partner, or employer of your debtor as third parties, to get information about the debtor that might lead to getting your judgment paid. I am a Judgment Broker, not a lawyer, and this article covers what I have done in California for judgments that I owned. The methods are similar in other states. To bring a third party to court, you need to get a court-scheduled hearing. You have to get a court (or lawyer) stamped subpoena, personally served on both the debtor and the third party. You may have to also at the same time, have a consumer notice served on the debtor.

You must pay the court for a hearing, and then pay a process server to serve all parties. You also need to fill in the right court forms (EJ-125), and use the correct wordings. That is what the rest of this article is about. There are two ways to go, when you fill out the paperwork, to comply with CCP 708.120.

One way is to use only page two of the EJ-125 form. Where it says (2) NOTICE TO JUDGMENT DEBTOR, type or better yet, use a fillable PDF on your computer and print, the reason to bring in the third party in this area, in CAPITAL LETTERS, as it describes, because you do not want them to have any reason to attempt to quash your subpoena.

Write something such as "JANE SMITH IS THE SPOUSE OF THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR AND HAS KNOWLEDGE OF THE WHEREABOUTS OF THE ASSETS AND OTHER NECESSARY INFORMATION REGARDING THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR TO AID IN THE ENFORCEMENT OF THIS JUDGMENT" or "JOHN SMITH IS THE EMPLOYER OF THE JUDGMENT DEBTOR AND HAS FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE EARNINGS WITHHOLDING ORDER LAWFULLY SERVED UPON THE COMPANY". All you really require something stating why you need to ask the 3rd party questions under oath regarding the judgment debtor.

If the reasons to bring in the third-party require further explanation, you must file a separate affidavit, declaring who this person is, the relationship to the judgment debtor, and whether they 1) Are indebted $250 or more to the judgment debtor, or 2) Likely have knowledge about the judgment debtor's assets.

On the EJ-125 form, on the back, you describe the judgment debtor's property under control of the witness, so you can effectively identify and lien the property, because a correctly served subpoena creates a silent one-year lien on any identified property.

On a separate affidavit, on regular pleading paper, using a standard format, write "Affidavit for 3rd Party Judgment Debtor Examination." For example, AFFIDAVIT OF YOURNAME, IN SUPPORT OF THIRD PARTY EXAMINATION OF MR. DEADBEAT DEBTOR. (or) AFFIDAVIT OF YOURNAME, ASSIGNEE OF RECORD, IN SUPPORT OF THIRD PARTY EXAMINATION OF MR. DEADBEAT DEBTOR. In the body of your affidavit, you say something based on your "belief and information":

I, the undersigned, declare as follows:

1. I am the (judgment creditor/assignee of record) in this case. I am over 18 years of age. I have personal knowledge of the facts herein, except as to those facts stated to be known upon information and belief, and as to those facts, I believe them to be true. If called upon to testify, I could and would competently testify thereto.

2. Judgment for the plaintiff in the above-entitled matter was entered on May 1, 2010 in the total amount of $XX,XXX.00 awarded against MR. DEADBEAT DEBTOR. The total amount plus interest and costs remain due.

3. I wish to examine MORTIMER SNERD, third party who is the (spouse, employer, etc.) of the judgment debtor.

4. I am informed and believe that MORTIMER SNERD has in his/her possession property of the judgment debtor, and that MORTIMER SNERD is indebted to the debtors in an amount exceeding $250. (Or that MORTIMER SNERD has knowledge of judgment debtor's assets - based on your information and belief.)

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.

Then, you should list your Points and Authorities to back up your request. What I have done (only in California) to bring in 3rd parties to court when enforcing judgments I own, is to include points and authorities along with my declaration for a third party examination try to find debtor's assets. Here are points and authorities I haves used, on the second page of my affidavit, and also placed in the third party request itself:

POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF ISSUANCE OF APPLICATION AND ORDER FOR APPEARANCE AND EXAMINATION OF THIRD PERSON

CCP 708.120. (a) Upon ex parte application by a judgment creditor who has a money judgment and proof by the judgment creditor by affidavit or otherwise to the satisfaction of the proper court that a third person has the possession or control of property in which the judgment debtor has an interest or is indebted to the judgment debtor in an amount exceeding two hundred fifty dollars ($250), the court shall make an order directing the third person to appear before the court, or before a referee appointed by the court, at a time and place specified in the order, to answer concerning such property or debt. The affidavit in support of the judgment creditor's application may be based on the affiant's information and belief.

CCP 708.130(a) provides that witnesses may be required to appear and testify before the court or referee in an examination proceeding under this article in the same manner as upon the trial of an issue. This includes the examination of any third person who has, or may have, knowledge of the judgment debtor's assets and liabilities. This includes the spouse of the debtor who, it can be reasonably calculated, possesses special knowledge regarding the income and assets of the debtor.

This understanding of the meaning of CCP 708.130 is corroborated by case law. While there is no case specifically dealing with third parties, the language of case law leaves little doubt that the scope of a debtor's examination is not to be unnecessarily narrowed. In the case of Kyne v. Eustice the court found:

The object of the proceeding is to compel the judgment debtor to give information concerning his property; and such judgment-debtor examination is intended to be summary and factual, according the widest scope for inquiry concerning the property and business affairs of the judgment debtor. (Coleman v. Galvin, 78 Cal.App.2d 313, 318 177 P.2d 606; McCullough v. Clark, 41 Cal. 298, 302.)

The purpose of such supplementary proceedings are to discover and reach assets of a judgment debtor so as to apply them to the satisfaction of the judgment. (Smith v. Smith, 51 Cal.App.2d 29, 31-32 124 P.2d 117; Coleman v. Galvin, supra,; In re Finn, 155 Cal.App.2d 705, 709 318 P.2d 816.) page 633

Accordingly, a third person or corporation alleged to have property of a judgment debtor or to be indebted to him may be examined concerning the same (CCP 717 now §708.120; Coleman v. Galvin, supra), and such proceedings may be properly used to obtain the possession of third-party debts after such examination. (Thomas v. Thomas, 192 Cal.App.2d 771,778 13 Cal.Rptr.872; Hathaway v. Brady, 26 Cal. 581, 589.) Kyne v. Eustice, (1963) 215 CA2d 627, 632, 30 CR 391

Further, in Young v. Keele, and cited in numerous subsequent cases, the courts asserted the wide scope of inquiry permissible in judgment debtor's examination, to the extent that its purpose is "to leave no stone unturned in the search for assets which might be used to satisfy the judgment." Young v. Keele (1987) 188 Cal.App.3d 1090, 1093 233 Cal.Rptr. 850; see also Troy v. Superior Court (1986) 186 Cal.App.3d 1006, 1014 231 Cal.Rptr. 108

Given the above, you, as the Assignee, requests that the court order the issuance of an Application and Order for Appearance and Examination directed to the above Third Party.

A Sheriff or Process Server will serve your papers, along with a copy of your Points and Authorities, so that it is clear that the witness is being served in the capacity as a person with knowledge of the debtor's assets.

Especially if the third party is a business, the link below is useful:

<a href="https://http://www.saclaw.lib.ca.us/pages/business-records-subpoena" target="_blank">http://www.saclaw.lib.ca.us/pages/business-records-subpoena</a>. aspx


About Author Mark Shapiro :

Mark D. Shapiro - Judgment Broker, <a href="http://www.JudgmentBuy.com" target="_blank">http://www.JudgmentBuy.com</a> - where Judgments go to get enforced.


Article Source: https://www.bharatbhasha.com
Article Url: https://www.bharatbhasha.com/legal.php/277672


Article Added on Wednesday, January 5, 2011
LD
Other Articles by Mark Shapiro

Lying Judgment Debtors
I am not an attorney, I am a Judgment and Collection Agency Broker. This article is my opinion, based on my experience in California. If you want legal advice, please contact an attorney. One of the best tools in the judgment recovery business is the possible power of a judgment debtor examination. Similar to many tools having potential power, as Eric Clapton used to sing, it's in the way that you use it. Payoffs from judgment debtor exams rely more on the examiner than the judgment debtor....

Turnover Orders At Debtor Examinations
I am not a lawyer, I am a Judgment and Collection Broker. This article is my opinion, based on my experience in California, and laws vary in each state. If you want legal advice or a strategy to use, you should contact an attorney. This article is about using one certain type of turnover (turn over) order which can be used (in certain states) at the conclusion of debtor exams. A turnover order may possibly get the creditor paid from cash, or the equivalent of of cash, that the debtor possesses...

Eliminating Judgments
Judgments are stronger than ordinary debts. Judgments are orders of the court that earn interest. Recovery costs and fees can be added to judgment debt. A judgment can be renewed, which often compounds the rate and amount of total interest owed. Judgments may be enforced any time a creditor (or a judgment enforcer, collection agency, or a collections lawyer) finds the debtor's assets. In a bad economy, many judgment owners are more eager to aggressively recover judgment money from judgment...

Communications With Judgment Debtors
I am not a lawyer, I am a judgment referral specialist (Judgment Broker). Please consult with a a lawyer if you require legal advice. Often it's worth attempting to contact a judgment debtor to see if they are willing to pay, settle, or set up a payment plan. Due to state and federal laws, you must be careful when doing so. It's legal to have a sheriff seize and sell a debtor's vehicle, with no advance notice to them. However, it is not legal to tell a debtor that will happen if they fail to...

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act
I am not an attorney, I am a judgment referral specialist (Judgment Broker). The FDCPA (Fair Debt Collection Practices Act) are a body of laws determining (among other things) how one may communicate with debtors. The FDCPA is both a guide and a code of behavior for debt collectors. Generally, the FDCPA protects debtors from creditors, and gives debtors rights and remedies for all creditor violations. As with many laws, the complete set of FDCPA laws is massive and hard to read. Some of the...

When you Can t Collect a Judgment
I am not a lawyer. If you need legal advice, contact a lawyer. Many people know that most judgments are never enforced. There are many reasons for this, some of which include: laws do not make it easy to enforce judgments, some debtors are frauds, and some debtors move to other states. The most common reason that judgments are not enforced is that many debtors are broke. Also, debtors move and it becomes difficult and expensive to keep searching for their new address or place of employment....

How Third Party Levies Work
I am not a lawyer, I am a Judgment and Collections Broker. This article is my opinion, based on my experience in California, and laws are different in every state. If you ever need a strategy to use or legal advice, you should contact a lawyer. Most of the time, the only way to recover a judgment is with the Sheriffs (or levying officers), courts, and often registered process servers; levying and/or selling a debtor's assets. Often debtors have assets with 3rd parties, where a judgment...

Getting into the Judgment Recovery Business
Most people make money enforcing judgments only after studying, working, and learning for years. (Ignore any web sites telling you this is a way to get rich quick or easily.) If you work hard and study, you can earn a good living in the Judgment recovery business. Like any business, success depends mostly on you, but partly on the economy, your location, and ever-changing laws. You can make money on judgment enforcements, the first way is to find (enforceable) judgments leads. There are many...

What Does Future Payment Mean
I am not a lawyer, I am a judgment referral expert (Judgment Broker). This article covers the future-pay concept on civil money judgments. Future-pay means you get paid later, after money is recovered, instead of cash up-front now. Every judgment, is only a piece of paper until available assets are found, and the judgment is successfully and eventually enforced. If the debtor has lots of available assets, you will probably get some money back quickly, however nobody can or should guarantee...

How Judgment Coops Work
Most judgment enforcers enforce judgments when the debtors are close to them, usually in their own state. When a judgment debtor moves to another state, it is more difficult and expensive to enforce the judgment. The exception is when the Judgment Enforcer (JE) travels often and works near the courts close to where the debtor is now. There are five ways of handling judgment enforcement when the debtor is not close to the current JE. 1) Work the judgment by remote control - paying for process...

Click here to see More Articles by Mark Shapiro
Publishers / Webmasters
Article ID: 277672
DELINK URL from Authors Bio
REMOVE Article
Tell A Friend
Leave A Comment!
Download this article in PDF
Report Article!
Search through all the articles:


255 Users Online!!
Related Articles:
Latest Articles:
 
Legal >> Top 50 Articles on Legal
Category - >
Advertising Advice Affiliate Programs Automobiles
Be Your Own Mentor Careers Communication Consumers
CopyWriting Crime Domain Names DoT com Entrepreneur Corner
Ebooks Ecommerce Education Email
Entertainment Environment Family Finance And Business
Food & Drink Gardening Health & Fitness Hobbies
Home Business Home Improvement Humour House Holds
Internet And Computers Kiddos and Teens Legal Matters Mail Order
Management Marketing Marriage MetaPhysical
Motivational MultiMedia Multi Level Marketing NewsLetters
Pets Psychology Religion Parenting
Politics Sales Science Search Engine Optimization
Site Promotion Sports Technology Travel
Web Development Web Hosting WeightLoss Women's Corner
Writing Miscellaneous Articles Real Estate Arts And Crafts
Aging


Disclaimer: The information presented and opinions expressed in the articles are those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent the views of bharatbhasha.com and/or its owners.


Copyright AwareINDIA. All rights reserved || Privacy Policy || Terms Of Use || Author Guidelines || Free Articles
FAQs Link To Us || Submit An Article || Free Downloads|| Contact Us || Site Map  || Advertise with Us ||
Click here for Special webhosting packages for visitors of this website only!
Vastu Shastra

Linux Server Hosting Provided By AwareIndia







Company IDS