bharatbhasha.com
Free Articles  >>  Education >>  Page 326  >> 

Education Activist Challenges Education Establishment Stop the Lies





Here’s what the USA is faced with: declining literacy rates and more than 50,000,000 functional illiterates. How could the Education Establishment get away with creating this massive damage to our society? The quick answer is they told a lot of lies. I’m asking them to stop.

For 75 years the Education Establishment has promoted Whole Word and tried to marginalize Phonics, as much as possible in both cases. Still today, after eight decades of disaster and dyslexia, and despite their own claims of embracing a more balanced approach, many schools and educators seem to have learned nothing. Check the internet and you’ll find that Dolch Words, Sight Word, Word Walls and the rest are enthusiastically pushed, as if they are some wonderful new invention.

This scam is built on one fantasy in particular: that humans can learn to read English using sight-words. Therefore children shouldn’t study letters and sounds, because it’s much easier to memorize shapes. Not true.

Truth is, almost nobody can memorize even 1,000 of ANYTHING. Consider flags, classic cars, celebrities, famous monuments or great paintings--pick the non-phonetic objects that would be easiest for you. How many could you memorize to the point where a picture is flashed and you say the name? Allow months to work on this. Throw in a big cash prize. Could you reach 500? 800? 1,000??

But you have to name them quickly. At least one a second. Otherwise, it’s nothing like reading.

Point is, memorizing 1,000 sight-words is like memorizing 1,000 sight-ANYTHING. Which is nearly impossible unless you have a photographic memory. (In fact, memorizing flags, cars, paintings, celebrities, or monuments is easier than memorizing English words, because our letters appear as lower and UPPER case, not to mention many hundreds of type styles.)

So, 1,000 is probably the upper limit for memorizing most categories of things, for most people. But 1,000 sight-words is merely the BEGINNING of literacy, which requires at least 10,000 words. Now do you see the problem? Whole Word demands that children do something that is not humanly possible.

Furthermore, during the many years when children are trying to do this mission impossible, their academic progress and self-esteem will be utterly destroyed. And all of this damage will continue for as long as our country lets the Education Establishment get away with this malfeasance.

So here is the essence of the Big Lie: that memorizing thousands of sight-words is doable. Frank Smith, the chief priest of Whole Word, airily announced that people can learn 50,000 or even 100,000 sight-words. Not true.

The little trick that the Education Establishment plays is to pretend that English words are a special kind of visual object, and if you look at them a few times, you have them for life. Not true.

The Education Establishment can get away with these absurd lies only because most adults don’t stop and reflect : hey, what is being asked of my kid here? That’s why I invite you to extrapolate away from reading to something else you are comfortable with--cars, paintings, faces, etc.

Try to imagine the staggering task of memorizing a thousand such objects--so you can name them with “automaticity,” as the educators say that children must do. Memory, you’ll find, is a fickle friend. As you fail to master 1,000 of your favorite objects, I predict you’ll be thinking, “Those *&+# educators are lying ^*%#@.”

Exactly.

But let’s say you hit 1,000. Congratulations. Bet you can’t hit 2,000. At which point you would still be a functional illiterate.

----
For a comparison chart that shows why Whole Word doesn’t work, see “37: Whole Word versus Phonics” on Improve-Education.org.
About Author Bruce Deitrick Price :

Bruce Deitrick Price is the founder of <a href="http://www.Improve-Education.org" target="_blank">http://www.Improve-Education.org</a>. His new book is THE EDUCATION ENIGMA--What Happened to American Education (order it on Amazon).


Article Source: https://www.bharatbhasha.com
Article Url: https://www.bharatbhasha.com/education.php/122498


Article Added on Wednesday, April 1, 2009
LD
Other Articles by Bruce Deitrick Price

Outspoken Education Site is A Teacher s Best Friend
Summary: Many teachers mistakenly think they have the same interests and goals as the Education Establishment. Not at all, explains Bruce Price, founder of Improve-Education.org. “It’s startling,” notes Bruce Price, founder of Improve-Education.org. “Many classroom teachers feel they are part of the Education Establishment, that small clique at the top making policy. I’m constantly surprised by this.” When people speak of the Military Establishment, they mean the generals in the Pentagon....

Hurray For Bob Herbert Education Wise He Agrees With Me
Summary: even liberal media are starting to realize that we are sliding into an educational swamp, most of it caused by liberal educators. Okay, liberals, everything’s cool. The New York Times -- preeminently, Bob Herbert -- has endorsed all the points I’ve been making the last many years. You may have thought these were extreme perspectives. Not at all! I and the New York Times speak with one voice on education. You can now enjoy my articles with abandon. I’ve been saying for years that...

What Do the Educators Mean When They Say Education
One word. Two different worlds. No wonder so little genuine communication--or progress--occurs in education... I had been writing about education for more than 20 years when I finally realized the divide, the scam, the silent sophistry, call it what you will, that renders so many discussions about education close to pointless. When most people say the word “education,” they mean something very specific, and almost everyone knows exactly what it is: reading, writing, arithmetic, geography, to...

What Republicans Left Out of the Pledge Education
I read The Pledge to America with growing respect. It’s written clearly and directly. Some say it’s too long. But it does cover all the bases. Except one. Republican leaders don’t seem to understand that Education is a huge issue, a winning issue. Promise to fix the public schools. That is what the public wants to hear. Education,” in the broadest sense, is the simplest way to understand why we have so many problems with our society and our schools. Simply enough, the far-left took over...

America s Most Urgent Business Aside From the Economy Improving the Public Schools
Public schools could do a lot better; everyone agrees. What nobody agrees about is the reason for their low performance. I call this mysterious mediocrity the education enigma. The question is: what the heck happened to American education? Remember, this country spends vast amounts of money on education, but somehow manages to create 50 million functional illiterates. You might almost suspect that our Educational Establishment is not genuinely committed to education as most parents define that...

Rush Forgets to Mention Education
Rush Limbaugh has been talking a lot about the four corners of deceit. They are, he says, Journalism, Government, Science, Academia. But Academia refers to colleges and professors. So Rush has left out one of the worst offenders of all. Education! Deceit? If Education had a middle name, that would be it. Education typically refers to everything going on in the public schools, K-12. This “everything” includes more funny stuff than a Saturday Night Live anthology. Quick review: in 1983 the US...

What do Knowledge Kids And the USA Have in Common
Here’s the common denominator: the Education Establishment is comtemptuous of all three. Do you think I jest or exaggerate? Not at all. The truth is straightforward, and easy to explain. In the matter of Knowledge, John Dewey and his successors made clear that facts, learning and knowledge were not, for them, primary. The relevant thing was each child’s social activity, because the real goal was a new social order. Knowledge was usually a nuisance, and often an obstacle. For the past one...

Unique American Intellectual Site Enters Fifth Year
At the end of 2009, Improve-Education.org celebrated its fourth birthday and reached 100,000 words of original content, recently adding such major new pieces as “41: Educators, O. J. Simpson, and Guilt” and “45: The Crusade Against Knowledge.” Bruce Price, the site’s founder, continues his aggressive critique of American public education. Price’s work is part of a changing narrative, as academics like to say. More and more, it’s common to distrust our elite educators. “Their approval rating,”...

The Busy Person s Checklist of Bad Education Ideas
Summary: Bad ideas are killing the public schools. Education activist Bruce Price describes the clunkers in 150 words. How do we improve? Easy. Get rid of all the bad ideas. ------------------------------------------------------- Okay, you’re a busy person. You have only a few minutes to think about education. Fine! That’s all we need to take a quick look at the 10 worst ideas in the public schools. Here they are: 1) Math is chaotically taught so that children don’t master even simple...

How to Teach Anything Everything
[Following is the script or copy for a short graphic video with the same title; find it on YouTube] improve-education.org presents HOW TO TEACH ANYTHING & EVERYTHING 3 little rules ------------------ First, decide to teach it. You make a list of things you want your students to know. You commit yourself to making it happen. This decision is huge. It’s half the battle. By way of contrast, look at what we have now. The Education Establishment doesn’t believe in teaching very much....

Click here to see More Articles by Bruce Deitrick Price
Publishers / Webmasters
Article ID: 122498
DELINK URL from Authors Bio
REMOVE Article
Tell A Friend
Leave A Comment!
Download this article in PDF
Report Article!
Search through all the articles:


117 Users Online !
Related Articles:
Latest Articles:
 
Education >> Top 50 Articles on Education
Category - >
Advertising Advice Affiliate Programs Automobiles
Be Your Own Mentor Careers Communication Consumers
CopyWriting Crime Domain Names DoT com Entrepreneur Corner
Ebooks Ecommerce Education Email
Entertainment Environment Family Finance And Business
Food & Drink Gardening Health & Fitness Hobbies
Home Business Home Improvement Humour House Holds
Internet And Computers Kiddos and Teens Legal Matters Mail Order
Management Marketing Marriage MetaPhysical
Motivational MultiMedia Multi Level Marketing NewsLetters
Pets Psychology Religion Parenting
Politics Sales Science Search Engine Optimization
Site Promotion Sports Technology Travel
Web Development Web Hosting WeightLoss Women's Corner
Writing Miscellaneous Articles Real Estate Arts And Crafts
Aging


Disclaimer: The information presented and opinions expressed in the articles are those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent the views of bharatbhasha.com and/or its owners.


Copyright © AwareINDIA. All rights reserved || Privacy Policy || Terms Of Use || Author Guidelines || Free Articles
FAQs Link To Us || Submit An Article || Free Downloads|| Contact Us || Site Map  || Advertise with Us ||
Click here for Special webhosting packages for visitors of this website only!
Vastu Shastra

Cheap Linux VPS Provided By AwareIndia







Company IDS