Free Articles  >>  Legal >>  Page 362  >> 

Personal Injury Pre existing Conditions What You Must Know

“Should I tell them about my pre-existing condition?” “Will it hurt my case?” are questions clients often ask.

You don’t want to hide anything about your medical history from the other side. First, you have an obligation to share the information. Second, a preexisting condition that is aggravated can mean more compensation than if you were completely healthy before the accident.

Take the case of Shannon whose car was struck from behind while sitting in traffic. There was no visible damage to her Toyota Supra. Ordinarily a low property damage case like this one would not be worth much.

However, she began to feel pain in her neck right after the accident and was taken to the emergency room. A CT scan revealed that a preexisting disc injury had been aggravated. Eventually Shannon required surgery.

When I presented a claim to the at-fault driver’s insurance they made no offer at all. This is often the case in accidents with no visible car damage.

After a lawsuit was filed and a trial date was set the insurance company settled the case for a significant amount.

The Rule On Aggravation Of Pre-existing Conditions

In all 50 states it is established that a tortfeasor (i.e. the person-at-fault, also known as the defendant) is liable when he aggravates a preexisting condition of the plaintiff (i.e. the injured person, the person who files the lawsuit).

The United States Supreme Court gave approval to this principle in United States v. Feola (420 U.S. 671, 685.) In the Feola case the person-at-fault assaulted a plain clothes federal police officer. He tried to reduce his liability by arguing that he did not know the man was a federal officer.

The Supreme Court did not care. It was irrelevant, said the Court, that the assailant did not know the victim was an officer. In summary, said the Justices, citing a well-established principle of American law, a tortfeasor "takes his victim as he finds him."

This principle is often referred to as the “eggshell plaintiff rule” in reference to an early English case where a man with a thin skull suffered death when a normal man would have only suffered a bump on the head.

Asymptomatic Versus Symptomatic Condition

The rule is applied differently depending on whether, before the accident, the victim was "asymptomatic," i.e. no symptoms or "symptomatic" i.e. having symptoms.

Here is a summary of the majority American rule on aggravation of asymptomatic pre-existing conditions as expressed by the Utah Court of Appeals:

"the rule is well settled that when a defendant's negligence aggravates or lights up a latent, dormant or asymptomatic condition, or one to which the injured person is predisposed, the defendant is liable to the injured person for the full amount of damages which ensue, notwithstanding such diseased or weakened condition."

The other situation involves a preexisting condition where pain or disability is present before the new injury worsens it. In that case the tortfeasor is only responsible to pay the victim compensation for the aggravation of the condition.

In these cases it is necessary to apportion between the preexisting condition and the worsening caused by the new accident.

Workers Compensation

The rule is well established that when an industrial accident lights up or aggravates a pre-existing deficiency or disease, it is compensable as long as the industrial accident was the medical and legal cause of the injury.


Knowledge of the law of pre-existing conditions is a "must know" area for anyone handling an injury case. Be sure to research and understand the principles as they apply in your state.


This article is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to take the place of competent legal advice from an experienced injury attorney in the state where you live.
About Author Rex Bush :

Rex Bush is founder of Bush Law Firm near Salt Lake City, Utah where he handles personal injury cases in Utah and throughout the United States and Canada. For information on personal injury issues visit his Utah injury attorney website: <a href="" target="_blank"></a>

Article Source:
Article Url:

Article Added on Monday, May 25, 2009
Other Articles by Rex Bush

Personal Injury What You Must Know About Traumatic Brain Injury
With the recent injury and death of Natasha Richardson from an injury to her brain after striking her head in a ski accident it behooves all of us to learn the symptoms of closed head injury so that we may be alert to their presence in a friend or loved one after an accident. Brain injury can occur from a minor impact to the skull. It can also happen without impact to the skull. This latter is known as a contrecoup concussion. Rapid movement of the head forward and backward can cause the...

Personal Injury Claim Should You Hire An Attorney
I'll answer that question with a few questions: Should you use a realtor when you sell your home? Should you use an appraiser to value your home? Should you use a title company when it comes time to have the transaction closed? Let's say you want to sell your home that you bought 40 years ago for $10,000.00. Someone offers you $35,000.00, you decide to sell because it sounds to you like a good offer. In reality, your home is worth $60,000.00 and you just gave up $25,000.00 because you took...

How To Calculate The Value Of A Personal Injury Case Eleven Questions You Must Ask
“What is my case worth?” is a question clients often ask their injury attorney. Here are eleven questions you need to ask and answer to properly value your claim. WHAT IS THE NATURE OF YOUR INJURIES? This is the most important factor. If you have a serious injury that has a big effect on your life you should expect more compensation than someone who has a minor injury that heals up quickly. A disc herniation that may require surgery is more valuable than a herniation that won’t require...

Traumatic Brain Injury What You Must Know
Traumatic brain injury is a serious medical condition that can extremely affect a person's life. It can be a confusing injury since it often produces a variety of symptoms that vary greatly from person to person. Symptoms can also vary in adults and children. The best way to learn about traumatic brain injury is to look at the different symptoms for each type of traumatic brain injury. Causes of Brain Injury Traumatic brain injury can be caused by any type of blow to the head. In many cases...

How to Select a Personal Injury Attorney 10 Tips to Jump Start the Selection Process
Getting injured in an accident is a miserable experience. Don't be a victim twice by hiring the wrong lawyer. Here are some tips to safely navigate the process. 1. Testimonials Read the testimonials in his advertising. Do they sound authentic? Or are they attempting to create an unrealistic picture. 2. Certification Is the lawyer certified in personal injury in the state where he practices. Many states don't have certification but for those who do it is an opportunity for a lawyer to gain...

Bodily Injury Insurance What Does it Cover
Sixteen year old Sally is southbound on I-5 near Eugene, Oregon. She hears a ring and knows she has just received a text message. After rustling through her purse, she finds her phone and checks the message. Her best friend Jane, back in Washington, has just seen Steven, Sally's latest crush, at the Vancouver Mall. Should I talk to him? Jane wants to know. Sally has to be in Ashland in three hours so stopping is out of the question. And besides, she has no problem texting and driving. She...

Car Accident Shoulder Injuries What You Must Know
Shoulder injuries in a car accident are common. They are caused mostly by the jerking movements that occur in an accident and may be further aggravated by seat belt shoulder straps. Shoulder injuries may also be related to neck injuries. Understanding more about shoulder injuries will allow you to recognize them quickly and seek treatment to prevent further discomfort and problems. Causes of Shoulder Injuries In a car accident shoulder injuries can be caused in three main ways. The first is...

Personal Injury Claim Should You Settle Or Go To Trial What You Must Know
A very important recent study has shown that, for plaintiffs i.e. the person who files the claim, settling is better than going to trial. The lesson for plaintiffs is, in the vast majority of cases, they are perceiving the defendant's offer to be half a loaf when in fact it is an entire loaf or more, said Randall L. Kiser, a co-author of the study and principal analyst at DecisionSet, a consulting firm that advises clients on litigation decisions. Most of the plaintiffs who said no way to the...

Personal Injury Act of God What You Must Know
What is an “act of god?” Black’s Law Dictionary defines it as “An act...[caused] exclusively by violence of nature without the interference of human agency. Typically these are events outside of human control, such as sudden floods or other natural disasters for which no one can be held responsible.” (Wikipedia.) However, if a contractor failed to follow the building code and because of that a house was blown away by a hurricane, the contractor could be held liable. What about a driver who...

Personal Injury Claim How To Do It Yourself 9 Must Know Steps To Top Dollar
If you absolutely cannot get a lawyer but you honestly believe you have a valid personal injury claim then you have only one choice: you've got to go it alone. Now, I don't recommend you attempt a bodily injury claim settlement on your own if you can get a lawyer. Based on numerous studies, you're likely to get more money in your pocket after paying your lawyer, than if you represent yourself. Just like any specialized area: there are pitfalls. (And you don't want to fall in a pit. After all,...

Click here to see More Articles by Rex Bush
Publishers / Webmasters
Article ID: 138129
DELINK URL from Authors Bio
REMOVE Article
Tell A Friend
Leave A Comment!
Download this article in PDF
Report Article!
Search through all the articles:

237 Users Online!!
Related Articles:
Latest Articles:
Legal >> Top 50 Articles on Legal
Category - >
Advertising Advice Affiliate Programs Automobiles
Be Your Own Mentor Careers Communication Consumers
CopyWriting Crime Domain Names DoT com Entrepreneur Corner
Ebooks Ecommerce Education Email
Entertainment Environment Family Finance And Business
Food & Drink Gardening Health & Fitness Hobbies
Home Business Home Improvement Humour House Holds
Internet And Computers Kiddos and Teens Legal Matters Mail Order
Management Marketing Marriage MetaPhysical
Motivational MultiMedia Multi Level Marketing NewsLetters
Pets Psychology Religion Parenting
Politics Sales Science Search Engine Optimization
Site Promotion Sports Technology Travel
Web Development Web Hosting WeightLoss Women's Corner
Writing Miscellaneous Articles Real Estate Arts And Crafts

Disclaimer: The information presented and opinions expressed in the articles are those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent the views of and/or its owners.

Copyright © AwareINDIA. All rights reserved || Privacy Policy || Terms Of Use || Author Guidelines || Free Articles
FAQs Link To Us || Submit An Article || Free Downloads|| Contact Us || Site Map  || Advertise with Us ||
Click here for Special webhosting packages for visitors of this website only!
Vastu Shastra

Multi Domain Hosting Provided By AwareIndia

Company IDS